The Van Scoy Legacy: A Tale of Settlers, Survival, and Courage in East Hampton
In the annals of East Hampton's history, amidst the sprawling estates and serene landscapes, lies the tale of the Van Scoy family—a story of perseverance, resilience, and unwavering courage that has left an indelible mark on the town's legacy.
It all began with the arrival of three brothers from Holland—Abraham, Peter, and Isaac Van Schaick, or as they came to be known, Van Scoyack. Each brother found their own path in the New World, with Abraham settling in Albany, Peter near present-day Hudson, New York, and Isaac making his home in or near the Town of Oyster Bay, Long Island. Though details of their lives are scant, we know that their descendants would play a pivotal role in shaping the history of East Hampton.
One such descendant was Cornelius Van Scoy I, the progenitor of the East Hampton branch of the family. In 1727, Cornelius married Patience Barnes, the daughter of Isaac Barnes of Amagansett, solidifying the family's ties to the region. Eventually, Cornelius and Patience would move to New Salem, Westchester County, New York, leaving behind a legacy that would endure for generations.
But it was Isaac Van Scoy, the first of his line to settle permanently in East Hampton, who would leave the most lasting impression on the town and its people. In February 1757, Isaac married Mercy Edwards and ventured into the wilderness of Northwest, or Alewife Brook Neck, where he carved out a life for himself and his growing family. With little more than his axe and his gun, Isaac cleared the land and built a humble abode for his loved ones—a testament to his grit and determination.
Over the years, Isaac's homestead flourished, and he built a larger, more substantial home for his family. Despite the challenges of frontier life, Isaac and Mercy welcomed fifteen children into the world, their resilience matched only by their boundless love for each other and their family.
But perhaps Isaac's most remarkable feat came during the Revolutionary War, when he found himself facing down British soldiers on his own doorstep. When the enemy demanded payment, Isaac refused to yield, defending his home with nothing but a hayfork and his indomitable spirit. His bravery in the face of danger became the stuff of legend, inspiring future generations to stand tall in the face of adversity.
Isaac Van Scoy's legacy lives on in the descendants who proudly bear his name, their stories woven into the fabric of East Hampton's history. Though no Van Scoys may reside in the township today, their spirit endures in the hearts of those who call this place home—a testament to the enduring power of courage, resilience, and the bonds of family.
As we wander the streets of modern-day East Hampton, let us pause to reflect on the pioneers who came before us, whose courage and determination paved the way for the town we know and love today. In honoring their memory, we ensure that their legacy will continue to inspire and uplift future generations for years to come.